| Service delivery | Community development | |
|---|---|---|
| Sees people as | Beneficiaries / recipients | Actors / decision-makers |
| Defines the problem | The agency | The community |
| Measure of success | Outputs delivered | Capacity & voice built |
| When it ends | Flow of goods stops | People keep acting |
| Main risk | Dependency | Slow, hard to count |
| What you did | Looks like | Actually is |
|---|---|---|
| Held an awareness camp | Participation | Informing (rung 3) |
| Collected feedback, then decided anyway | Consultation | Tokenism (rung 4) |
| Gave the SHG a seat, but no vote | Partnership | Placation (rung 5) |
| Community jointly plans & controls budget | Real partnership | Citizen power (6–8) |
| Tool | What people do | Reveals |
|---|---|---|
| Social / resource map | Draw the village on the ground | Who lives where, what exists |
| Transect walk | Walk a line across the village together | Land use, problems, on-site detail |
| Seasonal calendar | Chart the year's rhythm | Hunger months, work, illness, cash flow |
| Wellbeing ranking | Sort households by local criteria | Who is poor, by whose definition |
| Venn diagram | Circles for local institutions | Which bodies matter, and to whom |
| Timeline / trend | Recall change over years | History, shocks, what shifted |
| Model | Where | Known for |
|---|---|---|
| Kudumbashree | Kerala, India | State-wide women's SHG network & governance |
| SEWA | Gujarat & beyond | Organising women in the informal economy |
| Watershed programmes | Maharashtra, Rajasthan | Community-managed water & soil |
| AKRSP | Pakistan / India | Village organisations & rural support |
| Grameen / BRAC | Bangladesh | Microfinance & community institutions |
| Pitfall | Looks like | Antidote |
|---|---|---|
| Target-chasing | Forming groups to hit a number | Quality & function over count |
| Participation theatre | Meetings that change nothing | Share real decision power |
| Ignoring power | Assuming one 'community voice' | Power & inclusion analysis |
| Creating dependency | Doing everything for people | Step back, build local capacity |
| No exit plan | Collapse when funding ends | Design ownership & exit from day 1 |