Subject Pack · S3 · Interactive

Gender Impact Assessment Design

Move beyond sex-disaggregation to substantive gender impact assessment. Choose frameworks, operationalise intersectionality, and design reporting that does not flatten gender to a checkbox. Walk out with a GIA design brief.

4 modules~3 hoursInteractiveIndia-context

Your progress
0% complete
Your Capstone

Drafted GIA Design Brief

Walk in with a programme. Walk out with a gender impact assessment design brief -- framework selection with justification, intersectionality operationalisation, measurement plan, and reporting structure. Built automatically from your module answers.

Module 1 . ~25 min

Beyond sex-disaggregation -- what GIA actually measures

Sex-disaggregated data tells you how many women participated. Gender impact assessment tells you whether the programme changed gender relations. These are different questions, and most evaluations stop at the first one.

The three layers of gender analysis

Why Indian evaluations stall at Layer 1

Three structural reasons:

  1. Funder reporting requirements focus on sex-disaggregated numbers because they are easy to report and compare.
  2. Time horizons -- agency and norm change can take years to show. Check whether the evaluation is timed to when change can be expected or only to the end of the funding cycle.
  3. Measurement difficulty -- validated instruments for agency and norms in Indian contexts are scarce. The WEAI (IFPRI, OPHI and USAID, launched in 2012 after pilots in Bangladesh, Guatemala and Uganda) has been used across South Asia, but it measures agricultural empowerment specifically, not general agency.
Worked example (illustrative)

A long-running women's collectives programme in Uttar Pradesh: suppose external evaluations consistently report high participation numbers, but a deeper study finds that participation alone does not predict changes in intra-household decision-making. What matters is the duration of membership (3+ years) and whether the collective engages in public action (gram sabha participation, PDS monitoring). The evaluation then has to measure collective-level and household-level agency separately.

Your GIA Scoping Sheet

Fill these for your programme. Your answers save automatically and flow into the final capstone.

e.g., "NRLM-linked SHG livelihoods programme, 200 SHGs, 3 districts in Jharkhand"
Is this an 18-month midterm or a 5-year endline? This determines which layers are measurable.
Saved
Self-check
A funder asks you to evaluate the "gender impact" of a livelihoods programme. Their reporting template has one column: "% women beneficiaries." What is the most useful first response?
Fill the column and submit
Refuse the template and design a full GIA
Fill the column AND propose 2-3 additional indicators measuring agency or decision-making change
Explain that gender impact cannot be measured in one number
Correct. Meet the funder where they are (fill the column), then expand the frame. Proposing 2-3 concrete, measurable agency indicators alongside participation data is more persuasive than a lecture on gender theory.
Module 2 . ~30 min

Framework choice: WEAI vs Pro-WEAI vs GEM vs custom

Choosing a GIA framework is not an academic exercise. The framework determines what you measure, how long fieldwork takes, what skills your enumerators need, and what kind of findings you can report. Choose wrong and you spend Rs 20 lakh measuring the wrong thing.

Framework comparison

FrameworkMeasuresBest forIndia validationFieldwork burden (indicative)
WEAI5 domains of agricultural empowerment + Gender Parity IndexAgriculture/livelihoods with explicit women's empowerment theoryStrong (IFPRI South Asia)High: 45-60 min survey per couple
Pro-WEAI12 indicators across 3 domains; adds intrinsic agency, self-efficacyProgrammes addressing psychological empowerment alongside economicModerateVery high: 60-90 min per respondent
GEM ScaleGender-equitable attitudes on 24 itemsBCC programmes, adolescent programmes, norm-change interventionsGood (developed by Population Council and Promundo; adapted for Mumbai schools in ICRW's GEMS programme)Low: 15 min scale
Custom compositeProgramme-specific dimensions drawn from validated sub-scalesWhen no single framework matches your ToCDepends on sub-scale selectionVariable

Decision rules

The adaptation trap

Adapting a framework is not picking the items you like. It means testing whether the items measure the same construct in your context. The WEAI "input in productive decisions" item assumes women make agricultural decisions. In Jharkhand's mining-affected tribal communities, the relevant decisions may be about forest produce or wage labour instead. Cognitive pretesting in your specific context is mandatory, not optional.

Your Framework Selection

Choose and justify. These flow into your capstone.

e.g., "Qualitative life-history interviews with 30 women" or "GEM Scale alongside WEAI"
Saved
Self-check
You are evaluating an adolescent girls' life-skills programme in Rajasthan. The programme teaches negotiation, menstrual health, and financial literacy. Which framework is most appropriate as your primary measure?
WEAI -- measures agricultural empowerment across 5 domains
GEM Scale -- measures gender-equitable attitudes, adapted for Indian adolescents in ICRW's GEMS programme
Pro-WEAI -- 60-90 min survey designed for adult women in agricultural households
NFHS household decision-making module
Correct. GEM Scale measures gender-equitable attitudes, which is exactly what this programme targets. It has been adapted for Indian adolescents in ICRW's Gender Equity Movement in Schools (GEMS) programme. WEAI and Pro-WEAI are designed for agricultural contexts and adult women; NFHS decision-making items are for married women.