Subject Pack · S2 · Interactive

Livelihoods Evaluation: Design & Instruments

An interactive 3-hour Practice Pack on evaluating Indian livelihoods programmes: grounded in the Sustainable Livelihoods Framework, PLFS/NRLM/SECC-aligned, with realistic 2026 ₹ budgets. Fill the forms as you go; the capstone builds itself.

4 modules~3 hoursInteractiveIndia · India-context

Your progress
0% complete
Your Capstone

One-page Livelihoods Evaluation Design Brief

Walk in with a livelihoods programme (rural, urban informal, skills: any). Walk out with a defensible design grounded in the Sustainable Livelihoods Framework: outcome dimension chosen, PLFS/NRLM-aligned instruments, household sampling plan, seasonal data calendar, mixed-methods integration, honest framing.

Module 1 · ~30 min

Which livelihood dimension are you actually evaluating?

"Livelihoods" is one of the most over-used and under-defined terms in Indian development practice. A programme officer says "we improved livelihoods" and means anything from "households earned more this year" to "women joined SHGs" to "the village got a new road." Before any evaluation design, the field needs to make explicit which dimension of livelihood you are claiming to affect, and therefore measure.

The Sustainable Livelihoods Framework (DFID 1999): five capitals

The most useful organising lens. Livelihood outcomes flow from a household's combination of five capitals:

The vulnerability context (shocks, seasonality, trends) and policies/institutions/processes mediate how capitals convert into outcomes: income, food security, wellbeing, agency.

The four common outcome questions

Standard design dimensions still apply

The same three dimensions from any evaluation design hold for livelihoods, but with India-specific twists:

Illustrative example (fictional organisation, hypothetical figures)

Gangatir Livelihoods Society, a fictional society implementing NRLM in Bihar: SHG mobilisation + producer-collective enterprise + livestock + financial inclusion. The evaluation scenario is hypothetical, with a budget of ₹40L over 18 months. Funder wants "impact."

Outcome dimension: Vulnerability reduction (primary) + asset accumulation (secondary). Income alone would mask the smoothing effects of SHG savings.

SLF capitals targeted: Social (SHG networks), financial (savings, credit), human (skills training). Natural and physical secondary.

Design: Theory-based mixed-methods with matched comparison. Pre-post on a sample sub-cohort + retrospective recall on the broader frame. Honest about limits.

Your SLF + Outcome Decision Sheet

Pin down which dimension(s) your programme actually claims to affect, and therefore needs to measure.

e.g., "Gangatir Livelihoods Society (fictional), Bihar: SHG federation + producer collective + livestock + financial inclusion; 12 districts; running since 2016"
State(s), district(s), rural/urban informal/peri-urban
Which of the five capitals does your programme aim to build? Be honest about primary vs secondary.
"We will use this to...": with a date.
Saved
Self-check
A drought hits the year of your endline survey. Household income in your livelihoods programme is statistically flat. The control group's income dropped 12%. What does this finding actually show?
The programme failed: no income gain
The programme produced significant vulnerability reduction, not visible if measured by income alone
The drought makes the evaluation invalid
Wait another year before reporting
Correct. This is exactly why outcome dimension choice matters. The household's resilience to the shock IS the finding, because the programme protected income that would otherwise have fallen 12%. Reported as income, it looks like "no effect"; reported as vulnerability reduction, it's a substantial positive finding.
Module 2 · ~30 min

Choosing instruments that align with Indian data systems

The hardest part of livelihoods evaluation is choosing instruments that are both rigorous and also comparable to the data the rest of the Indian policy ecosystem uses. Studies that ignore PLFS/NSSO/NFHS instruments lose the ability to triangulate, calibrate, or be compared with national stats.

Instruments by outcome dimension

OutcomeAnchor instrumentsComparability
Income / consumptionPLFS employment + earnings module; HCES (Household Consumption Expenditure Survey); MPCENational benchmark; gold-standard comparability
Asset accumulationSECC asset list; livestock census format; NFHS housing/durables moduleStrong; standardised across major surveys
Capability / agencyPro-WEAI (Women's Empowerment in Agriculture Index); Alkire-Foster multidimensional measures; IFPRI agency modulesGrowing: pro-WEAI now widely accepted
VulnerabilityCoping strategy index (CSI); food insecurity scale (HFIAS); income volatility metrics; SHG savings recordsModerate; less standardised but well-validated
SHG / collective participationNRLM MIS data; SHG meeting attendance; bank linkage records; village organisation participationProgramme-internal; triangulate with independent survey
Qualitative livelihood historiesLife-history interviews; Stages-of-Progress methodology (Krishna); seasonal calendarsDetailed on agency; not statistically generalisable

Three livelihood-specific instrument cautions

PLFS-comparability matters operationally

Funders and government partners increasingly ask "is this PLFS-comparable?" before reading the rest of the report. Building 30-50% of your quant instrument around PLFS / HCES question formats means your findings can be benchmarked against national data, and your effect size estimates have something to be calibrated against. Lose this and your numbers float in space.

Your Instrument Selection Matrix

Pick instruments that match the outcome you chose in Module 1. PLFS-anchoring strongly recommended.

Anchor instrument matching your primary outcome dimension. e.g., "PLFS employment + earnings module (30-day recall); SECC asset list"
e.g., "NRLM MIS data on SHG participation + 40 life-history interviews + seasonal calendars in 8 villages"
Household or individual? If household, who answers? Note: defaulting to head-of-household undercounts women's economic activity.
Which of your modules use PLFS / HCES / NFHS / SECC question formats? Aim for 30-50%.
Saved
Self-check
Your livelihoods programme primarily builds SHG-mediated financial inclusion. Funder asks for a one-instrument summary measure of impact. What's the best choice?
Annual household income (PLFS earnings module)
MPI (multidimensional poverty index) household score
Decline this framing: explain why no single instrument can summarise a multidimensional programme
A programme-developed composite SHG-impact score
Correct. The funder's framing collapses the actual programme effect (savings smoothing, credit access, social capital, women's agency) into one number that under-represents most of it. The harder, honest move is to explain that 3-4 measures jointly tell the story, and offer to draft a 1-page summary that integrates them.